CalMac boss accuses port owner of 'lack of investment'

Calum Watson - BBC News
3 min read
0

The boss of west coast ferry operator CalMac has accused a private port operator of failing to maintain one of Scotland's busiest harbours.

Duncan Mackison said a lack of investment by Peel Ports at Ardrossan had left it in a "substandard" condition.

The interim chief executive warned that CalMac might have to switch its Arran sailings to Troon on a permanent basis.

Peel Ports said it had invested millions in Ardrossan in recent years, some of it to deal with damage caused by CalMac ships.

CalMac services to and from Arran have been badly affected by the emergency closure of Ardrossan's Irish berth earlier this year after safety inspections.

It was the only berth that the chartered catamaran Alfred was able to use at the port, and since then it has had to sail from Troon instead.

Another CalMac ferry can still use the main Arran berth at Ardrossan - which requires a notorious "handbrake turn" - but this cannot be used when there are strong southerly winds.

Ferries have increasingly been sailing from Troon, 15 miles further south, but there are poorer rail connections and the journey to Arran takes longer.

Mr Mackison hit out at Peel Ports, the private owner of Ardrossan, in response to a Holyrood petition calling for Clydeport, which is owned by Peel, to be nationalised.

"The berths at Ardrossan have had numerous issues over recent years, ranging from a fendering system that is very susceptible to damage, defects with the fendering system that have not been rectified in a timely manner, numerous failures of the linkspan and now the complete closure of the Irish berth," he wrote.

"This is a result of a lack of investment from Peel Ports, with the general condition of the whole port being substandard."

He said the condition of Ardrossan was all the more unacceptable given that government-owned CalMac had paid Peel Ports more than £15m in fees over the past 10 years to use the berths.

He continued: "If the current situation at Ardrossan is not resolved there is a risk that CalMac will have to operate the Arran service from Troon to ensure we can provide a reliable timetabled service for the residents of Arran and the many visitors who wish to travel there.

"However, operating to Troon will result in a reduced frequency of service when compared with the service that should be operating from Ardrossan."

Damage 'caused by CalMac ships'

Peel Ports rejected the criticism, and said it had invested "millions" in Ardrossan in recent years, and said CalMac ships had damaged the facilities.

A spokesperson said: “The port is safe and effective for the vessels that should be using the facilities.

"Indeed, there have not been any cancellations at the Arran berth in recent history because of maintenance issues, unless it has been scheduled work to address damage caused by Calmac.”

Outgoing first minister Humza Yousaf approved a multi-million pound upgrade for Ardrossan harbour six years ago when he was transport minister.

But the plan - which would be financed by the Scottish government, North Ayrshire Council and Peel Ports - was paused last year after the estimated £35m-£40m costs rose significantly.

In April Mr Yousaf told the town's local newspaper Peel Ports should "put their hands in their pockets" to fix the harbour.

Without redevelopment the two new CalMac ferries destined for the Arran route, being built at Ferguson shipyard, cannot use Ardrossan because they are too long.

Plans to build a dedicated fast refuelling facility at Ardrossan to supply the dual-fuel ships with liquefied natural gas (LNG) are also on hold.

Instead, Calmac will have to operate the ships initially from Troon and refuel them using road tankers which takes far longer.

Peel Ports said it had invested £2m in the Ardrossan upgrade project.

"We are willing to spend even more, if only the Scottish government and CalMac would agree on the specification and the business case so we can proceed, which we have been waiting for, for many years," its spokesperson said.

Advertisement

Recommended Stories

  • Congress exempts Boeing 767 freighter from 2028 production cutoff

    A congressional waiver on sunsetting Boeing’s production of 767 freighters to comply with international emissions rules will benefit FedEx and UPS. The post Congress exempts Boeing 767 freighter from 2028 production cutoff appeared first on FreightWaves.

  • Boeing Violated Terms of 2021 Agreement, DoJ Says. The Stock Is Dropping.

    The alleged violation exposes the company to potential criminal prosecution and, perhaps, additional fines.

  • Boeing Deliveries Slow in April

    Boeing delivered 24 commercial airplanes in April, the lowest number so far this year, as the company works through quality issues in the wake of the Alaska Airlines door plug blowout involving a 737 MAX jet. Boeing has delivered 83 MAX jets so far this year, down from 130 during the same period last year. Boeing's shares were recently up about 1.5%.

  • Airbus unveils half-plane, half-copter in quest for speed

    MARIGNANE, France (Reuters) -Airbus Helicopters showcased an experimental half-plane, half-helicopter on Wednesday in a quest for speed as competition heats up to define the rotorcraft of the future. The 200 million euro ($217 million) Racer is a one-off demonstrator model combining traditional overhead rotors with two forward-facing propellors in a bid to combine stability and speed, shortening response times for critical missions like search-and-rescue. The Racer, which first flew in April away from the cameras, buzzed past an audience of 150 industry executives, politicians and representatives from the European Union gathered at Airbus Helicopters' base at Marignane, southern France, where it has been gradually taking shape over the past seven years.

  • Summer holiday flights at risk as Boeing crisis leads to aircraft shortage

    Passengers are braced for a wave of flight cancellations this summer as the safety crisis at Boeing has left airlines scrambling to secure enough planes.

  • Boeing orders tumble as troubled aircraft maker struggles to overcome its latest crisis

    Boeing orders tumbled in April and were outnumbered by canceled sales in another sign of the crisis gripping the troubled aircraft manufacturer. Boeing said Tuesday that it received orders for seven planes last month, an unusually small number. As expected, deliveries of new Boeing jetliners were weak, at 24 in April, pushing the U.S. company farther behind Airbus, its European rival.

  • US airlines forecast record 2024 summer travel, up 6.3% over last year

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) -A group representing major U.S. airlines forecast record summer travel with carriers expected to transport 271 million passengers, up 6.3% from last year. Airlines for America said Tuesday that U.S. carriers plan to fly more than 26,000 daily flights this summer, up nearly 1,400 over 2023, or 5.6%, when they carried 255 million passengers. The summer travel season forecast is for June 1 to Aug. 31.

  • Boeing commercial jet deliveries drop by two in April

    Boeing also reported 33 cancellations for the month, due largely to Canadian budget carrier Lynx Air's ceasing operations, which accounted for 29 of the planes, Boeing said. Boeing has said it is producing fewer MAX single-aisle jets to improve manufacturing quality after the Jan. 5 mid-air blowout of a door plug on a 737 MAX 9 jet brought the U.S. planemaker under increased scrutiny from regulators. The planemaker said it delivered 16 MAX jets, down one from the same month in 2023, when deliveries were impacted by a supplier's manufacturing defect.

  • Boeing Delivers Fewest Jets Since Pandemic on 737 Max Slowdown

    (Bloomberg) -- Boeing Co. delivered 24 commercial jets in April, its lowest monthly tally since February 2022, as the planemaker slowed production of its workhorse 737 Max and 787 Dreamliner widebody to focus on improving quality.Most Read from BloombergTrump Vows ‘Day One’ Executive Order Targeting Offshore WindBiden Accuses China of ‘Cheating’ on Trade, Imposes New TariffsFlood of China Used Cooking Oil Spurs Call to Hike US LeviesHow One of the World's Oldest Hedge Funds Went BankruptMacron P

  • Sam Bankman-Fried Traded In His $35 Million Mansion In The Bahamas For A Prison Cell With 35 Inmates But Claims "He Did Not Do Anything Wrong"

    Formerly disgraced FTX CEO and Co-Founder Sam Bankman-Fried was convicted in November of wire fraud, money laundering and conspiracy, and sentenced to 25 years in prison. His high-profile trial marked a significant chapter in the unraveling of FTX, which collapsed under suspicious financial practices, leading to intense scrutiny and legal action. For the first time since his incarceration, Bankman-Fried described his daily life in a detailed interview with journalist William D. Cohan of Puck. Do