Green fleet transition faces financial roadblock

Alison Stephenson - Local Democracy Reporting Service and Jonathan Morris - BBC News, South West
1 min read
0

Costs of replacing a council's 41 diesel waste vehicles with electric or hydrogen models have proved prohibitive, councillors have heard.

West Devon Borough Council's annual fleet budget would buy just over half of a hydrogen waste lorry, according to figures discussed at an overview and scrutiny committee.

Deputy chief executive Steve Mullineaux said an electric mini-road sweeper alone would consume half of the yearly budget at £250,000, compared with its diesel counterpart’s price tag of £90,000.

A standard diesel refuse vehicle is £160,000 compared with £460,000 for an electric version, and hydrogen alternatives escalated the cost even further, councillors were told.

The switch to electric would also require a £500,000 depot upgrade for charging facilities, with vehicles needing recharging after about 100 miles, according to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS).

The vast majority of the fleet would have to remain diesel, but as technology progresses, prices would come down and some smaller vehicles could be swapped as they came to the end of their life, Mr Mullineaux said.

The overview and scrutiny committee heard that using the more environmentally friendly waste lorries had not been proven to cope well with very rural areas.

Mr Mullineaux said: "Exeter has been using electric and has been struggling."

He said a bid had been put in for government funds to buy a hydrogen vehicle for South Hams District Council, which shares services with West Devon.

Follow BBC Devon on X (formerly Twitter), Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to spotlight@bbc.co.uk.

Related internet links

Related internet links

Advertisement

Recommended Stories

  • What the Tesla Supercharger layoffs could mean for America's EV buildout

    The latest layoffs at Tesla this week cut close to the bone of the EV pioneer’s big competitive advantage — its ubiquitous Supercharger network.

  • Worsening Weather Is Igniting a $25 Billion Market

    (Bloomberg) -- Marty Malinow's mom never could get her head around what her son did for a living. To friends, she said he was “a stockbroker that does something with the weather.” Malinow couldn’t really object — he knew most people had no clue about financial contracts based on things like sunshine, rainfall and wind.Most Read from BloombergEverything Apple Plans to Show at May 7 ‘Let Loose’ iPad EventBerkshire Cash Hoard Scores Another Record as Earnings GainThe World’s Hunger for Salmon Is Li

  • ECP close to acquisition of UK’s Atlantica Sustainable Infrastructure

    Atlantica has assets across the US, Europe, South America and Africa.

  • The World’s Hunger for Salmon Is Linked to an Ecological Disaster

    (Bloomberg) -- Fermented herring, a Swedish delicacy, holds such a special place in the country’s culture that national newspapers review each year’s vintage and the first sale of the year receives hype akin to the first Beaujolais of the season. It’s also an acquired taste; social media videos abound of brave folks trying a food that smells like “eggs rotting in open sewage.”Most Read from BloombergEverything Apple Plans to Show at May 7 ‘Let Loose’ iPad EventBerkshire Cash Hoard Scores Another

  • New Florida resident Jeff Bezos pumped $60 million into making lab-grown meat taste better. Ron DeSantis just banned it from the state

    An announcement about the legislation went viral for reasons completely unrelated to meat of any kind: “It’s the worst picture of me,” a reality star says.

  • Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

    Three anti-wind power groups are suing New Jersey to overturn a key environmental approval for a wind energy farm planned off the coast of Long Beach Island. Save Long Beach Island, Defend Brigantine Beach and Protect Our Coast NJ filed suit in appellate court on April 26 challenging a determination by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection that the Atlantic Shores wind farm project meets the requirements of a federal coastal protection law. Atlantic Shores is one of three proposed wind farms off New Jersey's coast that have preliminary approval.

  • Renewable Energy Stocks Are Finally Riding the AI Wave

    Brookfield Asset Management announced a deal this with Microsoft to build renewable energy projects.

  • E-waste is overflowing landfills. At one sprawling Vietnam market, workers recycle some of it

    When he first started working two decades ago in Nhat Tao market, Ho Chi Minh City’s biggest informal recycling market, he usually salvaged computers with bulky monitors and heavy processors. Most repair shops are a single room crammed with junked electronic devices or e-waste with tables placed outside. Workers, many of them migrants from across Vietnam, repair or salvage items like laptops, scarred mobile phones, camera lenses, television remotes, even entire air conditioning units.

  • Cyclone Hidaya weakens as it moves toward Tanzania's coastline, officials say

    Cyclone Hidaya significantly weakened as it approached Tanzania's coastline, the country's meteorology department said Saturday. Officials warned residents to remain cautious, however, as the cyclone brings heavy rain and strong winds to the country through Sunday. The meteorology department did not say what the cyclone's updated maximum wind speeds were.

  • Nissan and battery recycling firm Ecobat partner in UK

    Project supports Nissan’s aim to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050 across operations